The Brutal Truth About Why Your Consulting Business Development Isn't Working

Have you noticed something strange happening in the consulting world?

Those brilliant, MBA educated consultants with flawless methodologies are struggling to fill their calendars. Ex Mckinsey partners are struggling. Meanwhile, consultants with seemingly "average" expertise are booked solid with premium clients who refuse to work with anyone else.

What's going on?

I've spent the last 24 months diving deep into this trend, interviewing over 200 consultants and analyzing dozens of training programs. And it brought me all the way back 20 years when I was a sales trainer.

What I discovered will likely challenge everything you believe about business development for consultants.

The Hidden Crisis Even Elite Consultants Won't Admit

Picture this: Marcus, a strategy consultant with impeccable credentials (former Big Four, top-tier MBA, 15+ years of experience) sitting in his office, staring at an empty calendar. His LinkedIn profile is flawless. His methodology is battle tested. He's invested thousands in business development programs.

Yet his pipeline was bone dry.

"I was doing everything right according to every consultant training program," Marcus told me. "I had my niche, my messaging, my outreach system. But something wasn't clicking with potential clients."

If you're like most boutique consultants, you might recognise this painful reality. The feast or famine cycle has become more extreme than ever:

One month you're drowning in client work

The next you're anxiously refreshing your inbox, hoping for a response

Meanwhile, overhead costs continue regardless of your revenue flow

And that gnawing fear grows: "What if I've lost my edge in this market?"

But here's what's truly interesting: It's rarely a knowledge gap that's holding consultants back.

The 80/20 Problem in Every Consultant Training Program

Most consultants already know the standard business development playbook:

Define a clear niche

Create compelling messaging

Build a consistent outreach system

Master consultative selling

Track your pipeline religiously

In fact, these five elements form the core of virtually every consultant business development program on the market.

Yet the feast-or-famine cycle persists.

After analyzing over 30 consultant training programs worldwide, I've identified the critical missing 20% that none of them adequately address: energetic visibility. And not just identified it, I've seen it play out in real life. I've listened to call recordings, I've watched pitches, and I've been astounded and how prevalent it is.

Why Your Energy Matters More Than Your Strategy in 2025

"In a world where everyone has access to the same frameworks, your energy is the only thing AI can't replicate."

This isn't some woo-woo concept. It's the new business reality in a post-ChatGPT world.

Think about it: When McKinsey quality frameworks are available through AI tools, when process templates can be generated in seconds, and when even strategic recommendations can be AI-produced, what makes YOUR consulting truly valuable?

Not your methodology.

Not your proprietary process.

Not even your expertise alone.

It's your presence. Your energy. Your way of seeing problems that no one else sees.

The Brutal Economics of Energy in Consulting

Consider these two consultants:

Want to implement this in your consultancy?

Book a free diagnostic to see where your revenue is hiding.

Consultant A: Highly credentialed, technically brilliant, follows every business development best practice, but delivers flat, energy-depleted presentations and content.

Consultant B: Solid credentials (though not exceptional), brings full energetic presence to every client interaction, demonstrates genuine conviction in their perspectives. They transfer their energy and conviction to the people they speak to with their sheer energy.

Who gets hired more consistently?

Who commands higher fees?

Who generates more referrals?

If you've been in consulting for more than a year, you already know the answer.

From Invisible to In-Demand: A 90-Day Transformation

Here's your implementation plan for overcoming the feast or famine cycle:

Stop hiding behind corporate jargon and started speaking with authentic enthusiasm

- Begin sharing your controversial perspectives rather than safe, consensus opinions. Do it with conviction and energy.

- Allow yourself to be visibly excited about client projects instead of maintaining a detached "professional" facade

- Focused on business development activities that energise you and delegate those that drain you.

Your goal is to hear "You just seemed different from other consultants we interviewed. More passionate. More present."

If you need support implementing this transformation, consider our business development coaching program or fractional BD services.

"This All Sounds Great, But How Do I Actually Do It?"

If you're wondering how to translate "energetic visibility" into practical steps, you're asking exactly the right question.

Let me share the framework that's helped hundreds of consultants break the feast-or-famine cycle even in highly analytical or technical fields:

1. Presence Before Presentation

Most consultants obsess over perfecting their pitch deck or memorizing client acquisition scripts. But presence precedes presentation.

Before client conversations, take five minutes to center yourself.

Ask: "What would I say if I truly believed my work could transform this client's situation?" This shifts your energy from desperate (trying to win work) to generous (offering genuine value).

One consultant's experience: "I was shocked by how different my conversations felt after this simple five-minute practice. Clients were literally leaning forward in their Zoom calls, asking deeper questions, and moving to next steps faster."

2. Conviction First Content

Most consultants create content and presentations on what they think will "perform well." The result? Forgettable.

Instead, start with conviction. What truth do you believe that others in your field either don't see or won't say? That's where energetic visibility begins.

3. The Energy Audit

Review your last three months of client interactions, content, and outreach. Grade each on an "energy scale" from 1-10. Where were you fully present and passionate (9-10)? Where were you just going through the motions (1-3)?

You ABSOLUTELY have to be recording your sales calls. Get a peer or even an AI program to analyse them on your level of energy and conviction. You'll be amazed and probably shocked at the results.

Congratulate yourself for identifying an issue and GET TO WORK on it.

4. Visible Vulnerability

The consultants who appear flawless also appear forgettable. True energetic visibility requires appropriate vulnerability.

This doesn't mean oversharing personal struggles. It means acknowledging real challenges in your field, admitting when you don't have all the answers, and showing your thinking process rather than just the polished conclusion.

The New Consulting Equation

The old consulting equation was simple: Expertise + Methodology = Client Value

The new equation adds a critical multiplier: Expertise + Methodology × ENERGY = Client Value

Without energy, even the best expertise and methodology flatline in perceived value.

Critical Warning: Why Most Consultants Will Ignore This Advice (To Their Peril)

Most consultants reading this will nod, think "that makes sense," and then continue exactly as before.

Why? Because it's easier to tweak your LinkedIn profile or rewrite your website copy than to fundamentally change how you show up energetically.

But while the majority continue fighting for scraps in an increasingly AI crowded market, a select group of consultants are already implementing these principles and experiencing results like:

Shortened sales cycles (from months to weeks)

Increased close rates (some reporting 60%+ improvements)

Higher fee acceptance (with less pushback)

More inbound opportunities (as their energetic presence makes them naturally more referrable)

From Theory to Practice: Your Next Steps

If you're ready to move beyond the feast-or-famine cycle, here are four actions you can take immediately:

1. Energy-First Content: Before your next post or article, ask: "What am I genuinely excited or concerned about in my field right now?" Write from that energy rather than strategic calculation.

2. Pre-Call Centering: Before your next client conversation, take five minutes to recall why you got into consulting in the first place. Connect with that purpose before joining the call.

3. Energy Tracking: For one week, note your energy level (1-10) before and after each business development activity. This data will reveal which BD approaches naturally energize versus drain you.

4. Conviction Inventory: List three beliefs you hold about your industry that might be controversial but that you genuinely believe. Consider how you might incorporate these perspectives more visibly in your work.

Remember, in an age of AI and information abundance, your unique human energy is the one thing that can't be replicated or commoditised. It's not just a "nice to have" it's your sustainable competitive advantage.